How much house can I afford in Jacksonville? Hands working a calculator over a real estate purchase contract.
Browse this answer and all topics

Every week someone tells me an online calculator said they could afford a house that the lender then said no to. Or the other way around.

The calculator wasn't lying. It just didn't know about your Florida insurance quote, your CDD, or the car payment.

I'm Jason Kindler. I've been originating mortgages since 2001, and I'm the President of First Coast Mortgage Funding. Here's the same math a lender runs, step by step, plus two worked examples that go with my YouTube Shorts.

Have a question about your own situation? Ask Jason Kindler, NMLS #157168. Call or text 904-734-3255, or book a 15-minute call.

The four-step method

This is how a lender gets from your paycheck to a price.

  1. Start with gross monthly income. Before taxes. Hourly pay is usually figured as hourly rate × hours per week × 52 ÷ 12.
  2. Apply the program's debt-to-income limit. Multiply gross monthly income by the DTI percentage for the loan. That's the most all of your monthly debts can add up to, including the new house payment.
  3. Subtract your other monthly debts. Car payments, student loans, credit card minimums, child support. What's left is the most the full house payment can be.
  4. Subtract the non-loan parts of the payment. Property taxes, homeowners insurance, HOA dues and CDD assessments. What's left is the room for the loan itself (principal, interest and any mortgage insurance). How big a loan that room supports depends on your rate and program, which is why a lender quote is the last step.

Step 4 is where Florida buyers get surprised. Two homes at the same price can land very differently once insurance, HOA and CDD are in.

You can run your own numbers with my home affordability planner. It works backward from the payment you're comfortable with, without assuming a DTI.

What lenders mean by debt-to-income

DTI is your total monthly debt payments, including the new house payment, divided by your gross monthly income. Some programs also look at the house payment by itself (the "front-end" ratio).

These are the published guideline limits. They're maximums, not targets, and plenty of files don't fit them for other reasons like credit, reserves or the property.

ProgramDTI guidelineSource
Conventional (Fannie Mae), automated underwritingUp to 50%Fannie Mae Selling Guide B3-6-02
Conventional (Fannie Mae), manual underwriting36%, up to 45% with credit score and reserve requirementsFannie Mae Selling Guide B3-6-02
FHA, manual underwriting31% housing / 43% total, higher with compensating factorsHUD Handbook 4000.1
VA41% standard, plus VA residual income guidelines38 CFR 36.4340

FHA and VA loans approved through automated underwriting can be evaluated differently than the manual benchmarks above. That's one reason two lenders can give the same buyer two different answers. As a broker, I can check more than one set of guidelines on the same file.

Why Jacksonville changes the answer

National affordability articles usually plug in one tax rate and one insurance number. Northeast Florida doesn't work that way.

  • Property taxes depend on the county, the city, the millage rates and your exemptions. A homesteaded home and a non-homesteaded home at the same price can carry very different tax bills. Your county property appraiser and tax collector have the real numbers.
  • Homeowners insurance varies with the age of the home, the roof, construction type and distance to the water. Get a real quote early. More in flood and home insurance for Florida mortgages.
  • Flood insurance may be required in some flood zones, and it goes in the payment.
  • HOA dues and CDD assessments are common in newer communities in Duval, St. Johns, Clay and Nassau. A CDD can show up on the tax bill instead of as a separate HOA bill, but lenders count it either way.
  • Mortgage insurance depends on the program and down payment.

Lenders use the full payment. So should you.

Example 1: How much house on $25 an hour?

Example only. This walks through the first steps of the method on $25 an hour. It is not a quote, a pre-approval, or what you'll get.

StepExample math
1. Gross monthly income$25 × 40 hours × 52 weeks ÷ 12 = about $4,333
2. Example DTI of 50%$4,333 × 0.50 = about $2,167 for all monthly debts
3. Other monthly debts$0 in this example, so the whole $2,167 limit is available for housing
4. Non-loan housing costsTaxes $275 + insurance $150 + CDD/HOA $100 = $525

The rest of the $2,167 limit is the room for the loan itself: principal, interest and any mortgage insurance. How much house that room buys depends on your rate and loan program, so it isn't shown here. Call me for a quote and I'll run it with real numbers.

Example only. Not an offer or commitment to lend. Assumes gross income of $25 an hour for 40 hours a week (about $4,333 a month), estimated property taxes $275/mo, homeowners insurance $150/mo, CDD/HOA $100/mo, and no other monthly debts. 50% is used as an example debt-to-income ratio, not a program maximum. This example does not use an interest rate and does not show a loan payment. Your payment depends on your rate; call 904-734-3255 for a quote. Your rate, payment, and approval depend on credit, income, property, and program. All loans subject to credit approval.

Example 2: What does a household need to earn for a $400,000 home?

This one runs the math backward: start with the house, then solve for income. Example only.

StepExample math
Purchase price$400,000
Estimated taxes and insurance$500 taxes + $200 insurance = $700 a month
Other monthly debts$450 car payment
Monthly debts before the loan payment$700 + $450 = $1,150
Income needed for those debts at an example 43% DTI$1,150 ÷ 0.43 × 12 = about $32,093 a year

That $32,093 is only the starting point. The loan payment gets added on top of the $1,150, and that part depends on your rate, your down payment and the program. The formula a lender uses is: (loan payment + $1,150) ÷ 0.43 × 12 = yearly income needed. Call me for a quote and I'll fill in the loan payment for you.

Two things the example does show. Taxes and insurance alone take about $19,535 a year of income at 43% ($700 ÷ 0.43 × 12). And the $450 car payment takes about $12,558 a year ($450 ÷ 0.43 × 12), so paying it off lowers the income needed by that much.

Example only. Not an offer or commitment to lend. Assumes a $400,000 purchase price, estimated property taxes $500/mo, homeowners insurance $200/mo, and other monthly debts of $450/mo (a car payment). 43% is used as an example debt-to-income ratio, not a program maximum. This example does not use an interest rate and does not show a loan payment. Your payment depends on your rate; call 904-734-3255 for a quote. Your rate, payment, and approval depend on credit, income, property, and program. All loans subject to credit approval.

Notice what moved the answer in both examples: taxes, insurance, CDD and one car payment.

Cash to close is a separate question

Qualifying for the payment is half of it. You also need the down payment, closing costs and any reserves the program asks for.

The lender's max isn't your budget

A DTI limit tells you the most a program will allow. It doesn't know about daycare, groceries, or what you want left in savings after closing.

Here's how I'd use the math. Run the lender version so you know the ceiling. Then run your own version starting from the payment you'd actually be comfortable with. Shop in the space between the two.

What can change your number

  • Paying off or paying down a monthly debt before you apply
  • A different loan program with a different DTI guideline or mortgage insurance cost
  • A co-borrower whose income counts
  • A home with lower HOA dues, no CDD, or a cheaper insurance profile
  • A larger down payment, a seller credit, or down payment assistance

Not every option fits every buyer. The point is to know which lever matters for your file.

Want me to run your real numbers? Call or text 904-734-3255, or book a 15-minute call. You can also start with the mortgage payment calculator.

FAQ

How much house can I afford?

It depends on your gross monthly income, your other monthly debts, the full house payment including taxes, insurance, mortgage insurance and any HOA or CDD, and the debt-to-income limit for your loan program. Lenders divide total monthly debts, including the new payment, by gross monthly income. Your actual number comes from a lender reviewing your credit, income, assets and the property.

What debt-to-income ratio do mortgage lenders use?

It depends on the program. Fannie Mae allows up to 50% on loans underwritten through its automated system, and 36% to 45% on manually underwritten loans. FHA's manual underwriting benchmarks are 31% for housing and 43% total, with higher limits for some compensating factors. VA uses 41% as its standard along with residual income guidelines.

What counts as debt in a debt-to-income ratio?

The new house payment (principal, interest, taxes, insurance, mortgage insurance and HOA or CDD) plus recurring monthly obligations like car loans, student loans, credit card minimum payments, other mortgages, and child support or alimony. Everyday bills like utilities, phone and groceries usually aren't counted.

Why does Florida change how much house I can afford?

Property taxes, homeowners insurance, flood insurance, HOA dues and CDD assessments are part of the house payment lenders use, and they vary widely across Florida. Two homes with the same price can have very different payments, which changes the loan amount you qualify for.

How much income do I need to buy a $400,000 house in Florida?

It depends on your rate, down payment, taxes, insurance and other debts. In the example on this page, estimated taxes of $500 a month, insurance of $200 a month and a $450 car payment take about $32,093 a year of income at an example 43% debt-to-income ratio, before the loan payment is added. The loan payment depends on your rate, so call for a quote to see your full number. That's an example only, not a quote.

Is an online affordability calculator accurate?

It's a starting point. Many calculators use national averages for taxes and insurance and may leave out HOA or CDD fees and your other debts. A lender's number uses your actual debts, the program's guidelines and the property's real costs.

Should I buy the most house I qualify for?

Not necessarily. A debt-to-income limit is the most a program allows, not a budget. Many buyers start from a monthly payment they're comfortable with and leave room for savings and other expenses after closing.

How do I find out exactly how much I can borrow?

Talk to a licensed loan officer who reviews your credit, income, assets and debts, and get a Loan Estimate on a specific property. A pre-approval based on documented income is more reliable than a calculator estimate.

Jason Kindler | President, NMLS #157168
First Coast Mortgage Funding | Jacksonville, FL
jasonkindler.com

Sources: Fannie Mae Selling Guide B3-6-02, Debt-to-Income Ratios (https://selling-guide.fanniemae.com/sel/b3-6-02/debt-income-ratios); HUD, FHA Single Family Housing Policy Handbook 4000.1 (https://www.hud.gov/hud-partners/single-family-handbook-4000-1); 38 CFR 36.4340, VA underwriting standards (https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-38/section-36.4340); Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, What is a debt-to-income ratio? (https://www.consumerfinance.gov/ask-cfpb/what-is-a-debt-to-income-ratio-en-1791/).

This article is for educational purposes only and is not a commitment to lend or an offer of credit. The examples are hypothetical, use the assumptions stated with each one, and do not include an interest rate or a loan payment; your rate, payment and approval depend on credit, income, property and program. All loans are subject to credit approval. Not all borrowers will qualify. First Coast Mortgage Funding LLC is not affiliated with the Department of Veterans Affairs (VA), the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD), or the Federal Housing Administration (FHA). This is not a government offer, nor has it been approved or endorsed by any government agency. Jason Kindler, NMLS #157168. First Coast Mortgage Funding LLC, NMLS #1953441. Equal Housing Opportunity.